Building a better shapes book [Which One Doesn’t Belong?]

IMPORTANT NOTE: The moment alluded to below has arrived! Which One Doesn’t Belong? is now available from Stenhouse as a student book (awesome for home reading, too!) and a teacher guide.

As a result, I have removed all links to the version I was previously distributing free.

There are many shapes books available for reading with children. Most of them are very bad. I have complained about this for years. Now I have done something about it. Most shapes books—whether board books for babies and toddlers, or more sophisticated books for school-aged children—are full of misinformation and missed opportunities. As an example, there is nearly always one page for squares and a separate one for rectangles. There is almost never a square on the rectangles page. That’s a missed opportunity. Often, the text says that a rectangle has two short sides and two long sides. That’s misinformation. A square is a special rectangle, just as a child is a special person. After years of contemplation, I had a kernel of an idea the other night. The kids are back in school before I am, so I had some flex time available. One thing led to another and voilá. A better shapes book. (Links removed—see above note.)

How to use this book

On every page are four shapes. The question is the same throughout the book—which one doesn’t belong? For example, which shape doesn’t belong in this set? 1 If you are thinking, “It depends on how you look at it,” then you’ve got the idea.

  • The bottom left shape doesn’t belong because it’s not shaded in.
  • The top left shape doesn’t belong because it only has three sides, while the others have four.
  • The top right doesn’t belong because it is the only square.
  • The bottom right doesn’t belong because it’s the only one resting on a side.

Maybe you have different reasons for some of these. That’s great! The only measure of being right is whether your reason is true. With an infant, you can use this book like any other shapes book. Look at each page together. Point at each shape and talk about it as you snuggle. With a young child, ask which one doesn’t belong and why. Most pages in the book have at least one shape that a young child can identify as not belonging. Join the conversation by pointing out a different shape that doesn’t belong for some other reason. With an older child, challenge yourselves to find a reason for each of the 44 shapes in the book. There is no answer key. This is intentional–to encourage further discussion, and to encourage you to return to the book to try again. I have tested the file out on the Kindle app on my iPad, and it looks good. I made one printed copy and prefer it to the e-version because I can leave it out for browsing and we can touch the shapes without accidentally turning the page.

The legal details

I owe thanks to Terry Wyberg at the University of Minnesota, who regularly plays the “Which one doesn’t belong?” game with numbers in professional development sessions; to Megan Franke at the University of California, Los Angeles, who adapted the old Sesame Street game “One of these things is not like the others?” and to my online colleagues including but limited to Justin Lanier, Megan Schmidt, Dave Peterson, Matt Enlow and Andy Rundquist.

Some additional prompts

The following Which One Doesn’t Belong? prompts are yours to use in your classroom or home. If you’d like to share them more widely, please link people here. Thanks.

77 thoughts on “Building a better shapes book [Which One Doesn’t Belong?]

  1. Pingback: Go Big or Go Home: Math Rocks Day 1 | Teaching to the Beat of a Different Drummer

  2. Pingback: Another Lovely Learning Day, Part Two | A Portrait of the Math Teacher as an Aging Man

  3. Pingback: Free Download – Which one doesn’t belong? Shapes Book | Kids Bloom

  4. Pingback: NYT – You blew it » Success

  5. Pingback: New year, new job | Overthinking my teaching

  6. Pingback: Which Mistake to Pursue? | Becoming the Math Teacher You Wish You'd Had

  7. Pingback: Talking Math with Your Kids update | Talking Math with Your Kids

  8. Pingback: Link Pack 3.21.16 | Teach+Learn

  9. Pingback: The Number Five in Beans | Playful Bookbinding and Paper Works

  10. Pingback: Straight but Wiggled – Becoming the Math Teacher You Wish You'd Had

  11. Pingback: WODB, Philly Style | Math Jokes 4 Mathy Folks

  12. Pingback: Trying to Merge Visuals & Math with 4-year olds | Playful Bookbinding and Paper Works

  13. Pingback: Which Number Doesn't Belong? Math Challenge for Kids

  14. Pingback: Smashing Fingers & Other Familiar Concepts – freer thinking through fresh eyes | Crossing the Curriculum with Katie

  15. Pingback: How Many? An invitation to #unitchat | Talking Math with Your Kids

  16. Pingback: Straight but Wiggled | Becoming the Math Teacher You Wish You'd Had

  17. Pingback: Learning at Human Scale (An #NCTMannual Wrap-Up) – Math in Unexpected Spaces

  18. Pingback: The Wonder-Full Wizard of Math and his Which One Doesn’t Belong? Books – Math Book Magic

  19. Pingback: S/he Who Does the Most Talking Does the Most Learning – By Abby Roza, Numeracy Resources Curator/Hennepin Cty. Corrections Instructor –

  20. Just found this book at the library and my 4.5 year old LOVED it. We read it as a family and each person chose a different shape and reason why it didn’t belong. He’s already asked to read it again tomorrow first thing in the morning. Thanks for making such a great thing!!!

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.